Season 2 of Tell Me Lies concluded with dramatic twists across the 2008 and 2015 timelines, leaving fans with shocking revelations and cliffhangers. From breakups to betrayals, the season’s final episodes packed a punch. Here’s a recap of everything that unfolded and what could happen next.
Stephen and Diana’s Breakup: A Calculated Move
Stephen (Jackson White) and Diana (Alicia Crowder) finally parted ways, though not in the way Stephen expected. While he believed the decision was mutual, Diana had been planning her escape all along. Her strategy even included faking financial troubles and keeping her father’s credit cards turned on the whole time. After their split, Stephen wasted no time, immediately sleeping with Lucy (Grace Van Patten).
A Messy Love Triangle: Lucy, Stephen, and Leo
Following her tryst with Stephen, Lucy quickly jumped back into bed with Leo (Thomas Doherty) without even changing her clothes. This small detail came back to haunt her when Stephen later used it as proof of their earlier hookup. In a heated confrontation, Stephen revealed this to Leo, leading to a violent outburst in which Leo pummeled Stephen, leaving his face unrecognizable.
Bree, Oliver, and a Surprising Discovery
Meanwhile, the secret relationship between Bree (Catherine Missal) and Oliver (Tom Ellis) is uncovered by Marianne (Gabriella Pession). However, in a twist, Marianne had known all along. She and her husband had an open relationship and chose not to tell Bree. This revelation came to light after Bree delivered one of the episode’s standout lines: “You don’t get to fuck me like I’m an adult and talk to me like I’m a child.”
Drew’s Tragic Overdose
One of the season’s most devastating moments came when Drew (Benjamin Wadsworth) returned to campus to see his brother, Wrigley (Spencer House). After a night of partying and taking Wrigley’s pills, Drew overdosed and tragically died on Wrigley’s couch. Lucy, feeling guilty for writing the letter that led to Drew’s expulsion, wanted to confess. However, Stephen manipulates the situation, taking the blame and using it against her later.
Evan’s Confession: A Wedding Day Bombshell
As Stephen and Lucy rekindled their toxic relationship, Evan (Branden Cook) revealed that he had slept with Lucy the previous year, cheating on Bree. After briefly stepping outside, Stephen returned unnoticed and recorded Evan’s confession. Flash forward to 2015; on Bree and Evan’s wedding day, Stephen sends Bree the voice memo just as she’s about to walk down the aisle. The episode ends with Bree listening to the damning confession while Lucy, her bridesmaid, stands beside her, oblivious to the chaos about to unfold.
Show Creator Discusses Key Moments and Future Storylines
Lucy’s Failed Redemption Arc
In a pivotal moment from the penultimate episode, Lucy reveals that she was assaulted by Lydia’s brother, Chris, which ends her friendship with Lydia. Show creator Meaghan Oppenheimer explained that this storyline was intended to highlight Lucy’s flawed redemption arc—trying to do the right thing but ultimately making a damaging choice. “It was probably the most contentious day in the writers’ room,” said Oppenheimer, as the team debated whether Lucy’s actions could be forgiven.
Bree and Oliver’s Story Concludes
Oppenheimer confirmed that Tom Ellis, who played Oliver, will unlikely return for future seasons. His storyline was wrapped up in a satisfying way, with Bree finally realizing Oliver’s brokenness and moving on. “I’m ready for Bree to be done with him,” Oppenheimer shared, hinting that Bree’s journey will continue without Oliver’s presence.
Wrigley’s Heartbreak and Drew’s Death
Oppenheimer revealed that Drew’s death was always planned but delayed until Season 2. “I wanted Wrigley to be destroyed by the end of the season,” she admitted, acknowledging the emotional toll this tragedy takes on Wrigley, who had a crush on Pippa (Sonia Mena). Wrigley’s emotional arc was crafted to show his downward spiral leading to the 2015 timeline.
Future Seasons: What’s Next?
Pippa and Diana’s Future
Fans wonder if the show will explore Pippa and Diana’s relationship. Oppenheimer hinted that while Pippa’s journey of self-discovery could continue, Diana may not fully understand or acknowledge her feelings for Pippa until after college. “Pippa and Diana don’t get together until after college,” Oppenheimer revealed, suggesting their relationship will develop slowly.
Diana’s Secret Plan to Escape Stephen
Diana’s shocking move to outmaneuver Stephen was a twist even some fans didn’t see coming. Oppenheimer admitted that the idea for Diana’s escape plan was conceived quickly when Hulu requested ideas for Season 2. Diana’s strategy begins in Episode 4, after discovering Stephen’s photos of Macy, marking the moment she realizes she needs to leave.
Lucy and Stephen’s Messy Reunion
The confrontation between Lucy, Leo, and Stephen was one of the season’s most intense scenes. Oppenheimer explained that Lucy’s shame and guilt fueled her actions, especially in her desperate attempt to avoid hurting Leo. This emotional turmoil was captured in a scene that felt like a “horror movie,” as Lucy faced the consequences of her decisions.
More Drama in 2008 and 2015 Timelines
Oppenheimer confirmed that future seasons will continue to explore both the 2008 and 2015 timelines, with a gradual shift toward more focus on the future. “By the third season, we will still have some 2008 because there’s stuff to wrap up, but I think there will probably be more 2015,” she shared. Fans can also expect a possible time jump when Season 3 returns, taking the characters into the next phase of their tumultuous journeys.
As Tell Me Lies continues to unravel its complex characters and dark twists, viewers can anticipate even more shocking revelations and emotional rollercoasters in future seasons.
